Should 6th graders play football?
by E.K. West
Oct 19, 2009 | 1014 views | 14 14 comments | 9 9 recommendations | email to a friend | print
An amendment request to the Gordon County School District Competitive Interscholastic Activities policy (IDE 2) for grades 6-8 was discussed at the Gordon County Board of Education meeting last Monday. If approved, the amendment would allow sixth grade students to participate in school football.

Scott Lambert addressed the board with concerns. “There’s no way an 11 year old can play against a 14 year old,” he said.

“I never let my kid play sports in middle school. I think they should have a chance to play sports through activities like rec football—there they will have the opportunity to gain that experience. I think it would be best if only seventh and eighth graders play ball in middle school. I really hope ya’ll don’t pass this. Thank you for letting me speak,” he said.

The Board decided to table the policy amendment for 30 days before putting it to a vote.

“There has been requests for the policy to be changed to allow sixth graders to play football,” explained Board member Nan Barnette.

“The present policy states that sixth graders are prohibited from playing football. The board has taken these requests into consideration and we are currently looking into the pros and cons of changing this policy,” she said.

The Board tabled two other recommendations during the meeting. A recommendation for policy IDF regarding interscholastic activities, competitive activities and student drug testing and a recommendation for a drug free workforce draft policy will be discussed further over the coming weeks.

In other business, an October spending resolution was passed and Superintendent Bill McCown stated to the board that proposals for future spending resolutions should be discussed as the District continues to wait for the Tax Digest to be approved.

The tabled policy recommendations and spending resolution proposals will be considered and reviewed in a called board meeting before the November regular meeting.

comments (14)
« it is what it is wrote on Thursday, Oct 22 at 01:11 PM »
Yes, Lambert is entitled to his opinion. But, if a person is going to show up and make statements in a public forum, they need to expect fallout. Also, the poster who used the word "idiot" wasn't referring to Lambert. They were referring to the board member who asked him to come speak on her behalf in the first place.
« Robert E. Lee wrote on Thursday, Oct 22 at 10:44 AM »
I don't care about the subject, but it appears to me Mr. Lambert's point of view is just like anyone else's, they are entitled to it. To disagree is fine, but to call people idiots and names is the behavior of a 6th graders or other children.

A hit dog will hollar.
« anonymous wrote on Wednesday, Oct 21 at 05:26 PM »
I've heard that the talk has been to get rid of the rule prohibiting 6th graders from participating, and then start a 6th grade team, where 6th graders will practice and play against other 6th graders. Not that Lambert's comments made any sense in the first place, but they certainly don't pertain to what is trying to be accomplished. We do have some very good school board members who recognize that this is a parental decision. Not all of our school board members support what Lambert was saying, nor do they support the silly rule imposed by one of our board members in the first place.
« AustinPowers wrote on Wednesday, Oct 21 at 11:28 AM »
I see Dr. Evil has requested another performance from Mini Me. I am sure she misses him not being at every board meeting to sing and dance for her on demand. I sure she is working on trying to clone Mini Me as we speak. Stay tuned to see if anyone gives into the master of deceit.
« anothercc wrote on Tuesday, Oct 20 at 08:00 PM »
girlpower-- You are missing the point. The issue is the fact that one board member is trying to interject their personal feelings into the household. Extracurricular activities is a part of all school systems. There are rules about grades, attendance, etc. which control whether a child can participate. No child should be restricted from participating in any activity if they meet the standards. We don't need a school board telling us parents how to raise our children
« girlwonder wrote on Tuesday, Oct 20 at 04:48 PM »
Umm, lessgovernment you seem to be confused. The right is to an education. A school sanctioned sport is a privilege not a right. Get it straight.
« lessgovernment wrote on Tuesday, Oct 20 at 04:26 PM »
This is just another example of more government in our community. It is time people take note of the individuals wanting to take our rights away. This community continues to have restrictions placed on it by local elected officals. This rule should not be in place. Watch these people, remeber there names, and what party they are affiliated with. Take note before your rights are taken.
« RecognizingBS wrote on Tuesday, Oct 20 at 04:15 PM »
JUST ANOTHER EXAMPLE of how one idiot can control the masses. Only in Gordon County!
« anonymous wrote on Tuesday, Oct 20 at 03:47 PM »
The reason it is now being brought up is because football is the only sport 6th graders aren't allowed to participate in. We belong to an association that has rules, and at all other schools, 6th graders are able to play. The thing is, no one is trying to mandate that all 6th graders participate. And, like posted, they still have a choice of rec ball if they don't want to go out for middle school ball. This is an old issue where one board member didn't want to allow this because of her personal feelings. Hopefully, we have a board in place now that will listen to the community.
« dawgs0215 wrote on Tuesday, Oct 20 at 03:11 PM »
Why is this begin brought up. The board made the decision to move the 6th graders to the middle school. So if this pass what about the other sports. Sports is a chance for kids (not parents) to enjoy sports. So if you do not want them to play middle school football and then put him or her back in the rec. program. It is their chance for them to do their best and get their name out because if you do not have money or your name is not know.The chance of playing on Friday nights are very slim and I hope their will be another high school built in the next 3 years because every kid will get a chance to play in any sports.
« GordonCent1990 wrote on Tuesday, Oct 20 at 10:25 AM »
I heard it was one board member who didn't want 6th graders to play football, and that's why they have this crazy rule. If we belong to some type of district or region, and they have rules that allows all other middle school 6th graders to play football, why in the world is this single board member wasting time creating a rule that only hurts our kids in the long run? Doesn't she have more important issues like the budget to consume her time?
« fhsgrad wrote on Tuesday, Oct 20 at 09:26 AM »
The real issue here is that certain members of the school board feel it's their job to interject themselves into the households of parents and make parental decisions. The decisions of whether a kid participates in middle school footbal is a parental decision. All 6th graders are not created equal, and parents, along with coaches, are able to determine whether a kid is capable of playing. Also, our member association allows participation from 6th graders, and to create some rogue rule by our board puts our local community at a competitive disadvantage. Lambert does NOT speak for the citizens. I would encourage all citizens to follow this issue closely, even if you are not affected by football participation. We need to be very wary of any government board member who wants to control decisions of parents, and remember how they addressed this issue come election time.
« gccitizen wrote on Tuesday, Oct 20 at 09:19 AM »
Why in the world is Scott Lambert showing up at a council meeting commenting as if he represents what the citizens think? His comments are crazy, and not credible. 6th graders should be allowed to try out.
« catb1 wrote on Tuesday, Oct 20 at 03:17 AM »
Why can't there be a sixth grade league developed just like the ninth grade has. They can practice along side the rest of the middle school players so they are in the system. There are some sixth graders far too advanced for recreation football.
Postings are not edited and are the responsibility of the author. You agree not to post comments that are abusive, threatening or obscene. Postings may be removed at our discretion.